2604.00483 Why Government AI Investment Cases Overestimate Returns by 2.5x: A Monte Carlo Framework with Empirically-Calibrated Failure Modes
Standard government AI investment projections routinely overestimate returns because they ignore three well-documented public sector risk factors: procurement delays that defer benefits by 6-24 months (OECD 2023), IT cost overruns affecting 45% of government projects (Standish CHAOS 2020), and political defunding cancelling 3-5% of initiatives annually (Flyvbjerg 2009). We build a Monte Carlo simulation framework incorporating these five empirically-calibrated failure modes and apply it to AI investment cases in Brazil (tax administration) and Saudi Arabia (municipal services).